Faith and Mystery- Going All In

Meditations in Motion

I was recently talking to a friend who has dealt with many running-related injuries. She asked me how I am doing, how I am handling my injury. I told her that I don’t want my latest marathon to be my last marathon. Even though immediately following the race, I said “No more!“, I don’t want to end my marathoning on such a sour note. I want to finish my final marathon with no regrets and good memories.

She asked me if I had any specific marathon in mind as my comeback race. I told her no, I just want to take a long time to recover and build up my stamina again. I don’t want to be pinned down to a race date at this point.

Then my friend asked me a question that I am still thinking about. “Why do you have faith that you will be able to come back?” Her question took me by surprise. I stammered out a response. Something like “I just do,” but I hadn’t thought about why I have faith I will be able to run a marathon again. I just do.

It made me wonder about the nature of faith. How and why do we experience faith?

If we are talking about my running career, why do I believe that I can do another marathon? Why do I think that this injury is not my last? I could rationalize this. I could say that I am in good physical condition, I am willing to put in the hard work needed for rehabilitation, and I have bounced back from injury before, but none of those are really the reason I think I can come back.

Meditations in Motion

The real reason I believe I can come back is something deeper, more intuitive, more mysterious. It transcends rational thought. Just like my spiritual faith.

When I have questions about faith, my go-to resource is the writing of Paul Tillich, a 20th-century existential theologian. Tillich’s definition of faith is  as follows: “An act of faith is an act of a finite being who is grasped by and turned to the infinite.” I like this definition. Thinking of faith as active is satisfying. It implies that faith is dynamic.


Meditations in Motion
Bust of Paul Tillich.   By Richard Keeling – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0,

Tillich goes on to explain that faith cannot be willed into being. It cannot be reasoned into existence. We must open our hearts to faith, to experience for ourselves what is true. It is not so much that we cling to a truth, as it is the truth grabbing hold of us and not letting go.

When we think of faith, we sometimes think of doubt as unwelcome, but that should not be so. Doubt means that you are thinking about your faith. I am a scientist by training and a high school teacher by vocation. Healthy skepticism comes naturally to me. Faith can survive doubts. It can survive close scrutiny. Faith is not something sterile and static that is never taken out and examined.

If we lived in a world of certainty, there would be no need for faith. The mystery of the infinite requires faith from a finite being. That is where courage comes in.

Yes, it takes courage to have faith, to believe in something that transcends us. When we put our faith in something, whether it is God or something finite (like being able to run again), we are gambling with a part of ourselves. We are invested in an outcome in which there is no certainty. Faith carries with it an unavoidable risk.

Tillich says that “Where there is faith there is an awareness of holiness.” And “The human heart seeks the infinite because that is where the finite wants to rest. In the infinite it sees its own fulfillment.” We, as finite and imperfect human beings, use faith to connect with the infinite, the unconditional, in order to be completely fulfilled.

Meditations in Motion

The catch here is that there is no conditional way to connect with the unconditional. In other words, there is no such thing as lukewarm faith. It’s all or nothing. We can’t hedge our bets. That is why, when Christ was asked which commandment was the most important, answered: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind.” Faith requires us to go all in.

So, I need to ask myself “Am I willing to go all in?” In the case of my spiritual faith and the faith in my ability to stage a running comeback, my answer must be an unhesitant and enthusiastic “Yes.” Yes, I am willing to take that risk. Yes, I am already all in. I don’t have a choice, not really. This is my truth. I do have faith, and faith is active. I had better get moving.

Meditations in Motion


I am linking up with Char at Trekking Thru, Abounding Grace for Gracefull Tuesday, Patty, Erika and Marcia for Tuesdays on the Run, Shank You Very Much for her Dream Team Running on Happy, Crazy Running Girl, and Coach Debbie Runs  for Coaches’ Corner linkup, Nicole and Annmarie for Wild Workout Wednesday, Holley Gerth for Coffee for Your Heart,Eclectic Evelyn for her Words on Wednesday, Worth Beyond Rubies, Sharing a Journey for Wellness Wednesday, Debbie at Dare 2 Hear, It’s a Small Town Life for Thankful Thursday, and Meghan Weyerbacher for Tea and Word.






  1. I completely relate to this, as I have just made my way back from nerve damage in my shoulder that prevented me from participating in my aerial practice for 6 months. Although it seemed hopeless at times, I knew there was no option but to recover. It’s still an ongoing journey for me, but I’m certainly getting there. I love how you quoted part of the Shema- “love the lord, your God…,” which is one of the most important prayers in Judaism. I look forward to reading more about your recovery and comeback!! You got this!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I love this! Thank you for sharing in such a thoughtful manner… I think I will be reading more of Tillich! Have you read much of Frederick Buechner? I only recently discovered him, and he a wonderful thinker and writer…like Tillich and Lewis…maybe a bit more personal in a way.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. It’s all or nothing. How true! There is an aspect to faith of not having the facts to back it up in every essence, but that’s when I’m so thankful for the Holy Spirit speaking to us, reminding us that our hope will not disappoint if placed in Him! Enjoyed being your neighbor on #GraceFullTuesday today. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I think faith is an incredibly important thing to have, to have faith in anything makes most of life’s difficult situations easier to manage and easier to come to terms with. I am a spiritual person but definitely not religious and my faith helps me a lot in life x #dreamteam

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Excellent post. The faith we have in Christ guides us to have the faith in ourselves to accomplish the tasks we have at hand. Good luck in getting back into condition for the marathon. Let God’s grace guide you together with your faith to accomplish your goal.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Another deeply thoughtful post — both inspiring and challenging. One thought I have about faith is that it also means letting go of attachment to results, as we wish and hope they will be. We can and probably should reach for the stars, but if we don’t grasp them, faith means we trust there is something larger than our own aims at work, and we are vastly better off if we trust it. That thought has helped me through some rough times, anyway.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I sort of gasped as I read that someone questioned your intention to make a comeback from injury. My knee-jerk reaction was “how dare she?” Of course you’ll come back! That’s the optimist in me. I don’t know that I am faithful as much as I am optimistic. Where there’s a will there’s a way.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Haha! Marcia, I have to tell you, you remind me so much of a dear running friend of mine named Doris. I can just picture her saying “How dare she?” in that situation too! 🙂


  8. Your faith inspires me. I worry too much and don’t fall back on faith. Faith should not be hard, but it is. I pray daily for my unbelief. Thanks for sharing on the #LMMLinkup this week.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Wow – I wouldn’t know what to say if someone asked me a question like that. After my horrible marathon experience in Chicago, I got nothing but support when I announced I was going to run another one.

    Although I’m not a weekly churchgoer, I do have Faith and that belief weaves it way through everything in my life – running, work, family, etc.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I forget where I read this, and I am not going to get the quote exactly right but it goes something like this: “Faith does not mean believing in something that is unbelievable. It’s not a test.”


  10. Faith is that little voice inside me that tells me to keep going. Press on and don’t stop. How can we get along without it?

    Thank you for linking up today. I always enjoy your posts.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s